
Hi Sian. I didn't love it, but I didn't hate it, either. I had a bit of a problem with the way some characters were presented: the black girl was fat and talked "street", the teacher's wife wanted a child so she had to also be a horribled shrew, the guy in the wheelchair was bullied and not even credited with a personality (the show's been heavily criticised in the US for its portrayal of disabled people, and I think some of those concerns are valid). I guess they are about to challenge some stereotypes as it's hard to believe they'd be that lazy, but I wish they had done so from the start. With the exception of My So Called Life, which is a classic, I also think that storytelling through narration rather than dialogue is the mark of weak writing (one reason Desperate Housewives isn't as clever as it thinks it is). BUT I really liked the sing and dance numbers and am fascinated with the idea of a glee club, and found the teacher likeable (though the redheaded stalker lady is not. She's annoying. And I hated her in Ugly Betty.) I like Jane Lynch (as long as she can rein it in) and thought she was funny. But overall the show has an edgy feel - not as in "we're so cool", as in "something nasty's probably about to happen" which meant I couldn't quite relax into it. It's not a cosily self-indulgent watch like One Tree Hill (which I LOVE) nor is it as dark and clever as it thinks. It's occupying an uneasy middle ground, and I'll be interested to see how it progresses. Diane x
Hi Anonymous, I really didn't like the show. I wouldn't bother bashing something just to be different, but I was shocked how many people I knew who enjoyed it - even they weren't expecting to. As a review, I think it still stands. It doesn't work for me. The storyline is weak, the characters are bland and the singing and dancing isn't enough to carry it. What did you think of it? Sian








12/01/2010 - 03:20
Lame. To be honest it sounds like you are bashing it just to be 'different' or controversial. Aside from commenting on other shows, this is not much of an actual review. Especially when you spend the first paragraph talking about yourself. Fortunately, I doubt whatever you think is going to burst anyone's bubble. Also, please note the correct use of the apostrophe and watch out for Americanisation of your commas.